• Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Policy
  • Guest Post
  • Archive

One Cent At A Time

A Personal finance blog to get rich

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Beautiful Life
  • Becoming Rich
  • Beginners Guide
  • Extra Income
  • Productivity
  • Saving Money

Robo-Advisors or Human Advisor for Your Investment

September 9, 2016 7 Comments

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Robo-Advisors…should you or should you not? Today, I hope to shed some light on this topic to help you make the decision that’s best for you. As you may already be aware, Robo-Advisors have become more popular lately due to the low cost to investors. 

Robo-Advisors or Human Advisor for Your Investment

These programs are built on platforms with algorithms designed to advise the investor on what funds they should be investing in.  The program asks the investor pre-programed questions and based on those answers determines the recommended portfolio.

What About Cost?

Since a computer is doing the work,opposed to an actual human, naturally the cost will be lower. However, when deciding if this approach is right for you, it is important to research all the different companies in terms of fees and services offered. Even though the cost may be lower, fees vary from company to company.

How do they really work?

Each company may have a different method they use when building their algorithms to determine investment choices.

The Robo-Advisor firm will share their method with you which you can generally find on their company website.  It is important to understand this methodology to make sure it is in line with your own philosophy and objectives when it comes to investing.

Another critical component to consider is, what family of funds they are choosing from? Are they just sticking to a few fund families? The greater the diversity of fund families they have to choose from the better it will be for the investor.

Reason being, just because one fund family has a great growth fund does not mean that same fund family will also have the best international, bond, or even value fund as well.

So the more fund family offerings they have available, the better the chance an investor has of getting closer to a“best of breed” situation.

There are thousands of exchange traded funds available to investors so, you want to make sure you have the absolute best available not just the best within a particular family?

This is why it is so important for investors to compare the pool of funds the robot-advisor companies have to choose from.

More to Consider

To simplify, let’s review.What are some of the basic considerations you want to examine if you are considering using a robo-advisor for your investments?

First, as with anything, you will want to compare the firm in terms of service and reputation.  With online surveys and ratings readily available, it is easy to do this type of research by reading what other people are saying about their experiences with the particular firms you are considering.

Take the time to understand the method behind the algorithms their programs is built upon. Which method makes the most sense to you?  How many fund families are they working with?

The user-friendly platform is very important as well.  Explore the various services available and compare the quality and usefulness of those services and tools as compared to competing websites.

What is the quality of their customer service and is their contact information readily available? Are their representatives knowledgeable?

For many customers today, an important concern when contacting customer service is whether you are speaking with a representative in the states vs. overseas.

Robo-Advisor vs. Real Life Advisor

Now for the million dollar question! Should you use a Robo-Advisor or a Human?

In order to answer this question accurately, it is important to understand that just as there are different types of Robo-Advisor programs, there are also many different types of Human Advisors.

Some advisors only advise their clients regarding investments and help manage their portfolios.  So,in comparing a human to a computer, a complete comparison must be done to determine the overall track record and performance over the long haul.

There is plenty of evidence that will indicate how human advisors aren’t always able to beat the indexes, so with this in mind, are you are better off just investing in an index?

If this is the case, then you may be better off investing in an index like S&P 500.

If this is the route you take, you can do this on your own without a robo-advisor and save yourself, even more, fees.  However, most are looking for more diversification than that.

Holistic Advice

Since we are comparing, let’s take it a step further and discuss the human advisor whose focus is on a more holistic plan than one who simply chooses your investments for you. The big argument for using a robo-advisor is fewer fees.

In life, most of the time, you get what you pay for. For some individuals, they are seeking an advisor that can help them with more than just investments.

This is where a holistic planner is key. The holistic planner is going to get to know you, your family and life concern on a more personal level. They will closely focus on your goals and objectives now and into the future.

They will be equipped to assist you with not only your investments, but also with your taxes, insurance, special family needs, income planning, retirement planning, and just about any financial concern you may have.

In my experience, the biggest concern that many of my people have is that they have one person managing their investments,another handling their trust and will,another preparing their taxes and yet another advising on their insurance needs.

With all of this advice, most don’t even have anyone advising them as to how they can maximize their pension and social security benefits.

The challenge they have here is that none of these professionals are communicating to each other and therefore things fall through the cracks and their financial planning and strategy are not as efficient as it could be, as one hand does not know what the other hand is doing.

In Conclusion

In conclusion and to summarize some of what we have already discussed, here are some final considerations that will help determine what road you would benefit from.

What would the benefit of saving 1% on fees be by using a robo-advisor if you are losing a whopping 15 to 20 percent in taxes?

Or, let’s say your retirement plan is not arranged properly and you are losing 20% in additional potential income throughout your retirement because your pension and social security planning was not handled properly.

Then, there are families who have children with disabilities. A plan must be put in place to oversee and ensure the proper care of this child in the event something should happen to the current caregiver.  The list goes on and on.

So when it comes to deciding between Robo or Human advisor, it is important to consider your fees and what you are getting in return for those fees. We must be careful not to be penny wise and pound foolish.

Most of us are not experts in all things related to investing and finances and this is the reason it is best to seek out and hire individuals to handle those things we are unable to, don’t have the appropriate knowledge of or simply can’t or don’t have the desire to manage.

A holistic planner will work to help you become and remain financially fit, much like a coach or trainer will work with you to improve your physical fitness and well-being.

In addition, a holistic planner will quarterback all the aspects of your financial plan. They will help you to put in place and maintain a plan over the years and ensure that you are on the right track as well as proactively help to adjust as life, the economy, and circumstances change.

Changes in life, the economy or any other real life occurrence, would be better managed by a Human Advisor who will have the ability to proactively advise you when a new law comes into effect or tax changes occur where they can make adjustments that will benefit you.

Unfortunately, an algorithm won’t call you up and tell you there is a new tax law I feel you can take advantage of why do you come in so we can talk about it.

A human Advisor can help you take advantage of quick decisions based on sudden opportunities because they know you and your situation on a personal level.

So do your research to determine what will be the best fit for your base on the big picture, not just fees alone.

About the Author: Rick Rivera is a partner at Safeguard Investment Advisory Group (www.safeguardinvestment.com) and has more than two decades of experience in the financial industry providing guidance to those planning for retirement. He is an investment advisor representative holding a series 65 license, as well as Life-Only and Accident and Health licenses in California.

LIKE THIS POST?
I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Join our community of 8000+ subscribers to increase your net worth and build wealth
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
The tool that changed the way I manage my personal finance - Personal Capital, The Best Free Personal Finance Tool

Want to start a WordPress blog now? The onecentatatime.com blog is hosted by Siteground Web Hosting. For only $3.95 a month, Siteground can help you set up and host your website/blog quickly and easily.

About the Blogger Hi I am SB, a personal finance enthusiast with a career in software development. I am an immigrant to the USA since 2005, after being born and brought up in India. This 40 something technocrat lives and breathes personal finance whenever he gets time from the day job, job as a husband and a dad

Some links on this page may be affiliate links, if you make a purchase following the links, I may earn a commission. Read affiliate disclosure here
« 9 Things About Student Loan Forgiveness
Looking for the Best Shopping deals? »

Comments

  1. Brad, Financial Coach says

    September 9, 2016 at 8:07 AM

    I’ve a very satisfied Betterment customer. It may not be for everyone, but I certainly recommend everyone at least take a look at this option. Total costs run around .3% annually versus 2%+ with an advisor. That 2% is a LOT of money once you have substantial investments.

    BTW, I mean “total” costs as-in not just the platform or advisor fee but also any fund/ETF/trade/etc fees.

    Reply
    • SB says

      September 9, 2016 at 9:23 PM

      I use PersonalCapital and am a fan of it. Some of Rick’s arguments do resonate with me, for example, tax situation or special situation in your family, etc. Where a human advisor would definitely make more sense.

      Reply
  2. Fehmeen says

    September 9, 2016 at 8:10 AM

    I’m surprised to learn the investment industry has automated to such an extent that robo-advisers exist! And for me, I think the biggest issue is that of trust, even if robo-advisors somehow do manage to beat the market. Another thing to understand is that investors should never blindly trust their own brokers (unless they have a great long standing relationship), or a computerized software (because one little glitch can land you in trouble).

    Reply
    • SB says

      September 9, 2016 at 9:26 PM

      Right, robots can’t help you if you have one of a kind financial situation. I am a fan of robo advisors since I started using PersonalCapital. But some sudden change in socio-economic landscape or in your family are exceptions where you must go to a human for advise.

      Reply
  3. Ray Ray says

    September 9, 2016 at 3:57 PM

    I can’t wait for Betterment to hit Australian shores! Bring it on!

    Reply
    • SB says

      September 9, 2016 at 9:29 PM

      Don’t you have any other tools there?

      Reply
  4. Nick Vail says

    September 16, 2016 at 10:49 AM

    As a financial advisor, I do believe there are some great benefits to the robo advisor platform, especially for the young investor. If your advisor isn’t bringing any value to the table other than investment management, go the robo route. However, working with an advisor that does holistic planning can make a HUGE difference in your financial life. Consider things like navigating student loans, estate planning, protecting your family with life insurance and long-term care, as well as behavioral finance (helping investors make prudent decisions during tough times) and you can see how a holistic financial plan is much more than investing. This is where a financial advisor can add a ton of value to the lives of his/her clients.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



Create your own blog in 20 minutes and $20

Personal Capital, a free tool to change your financial health today

I use and suggest Upstart, for your personal loan need

CreditKarma, a free tool to check your credit scorey

I use Coinbase, for my crypto investments

101 Cents at a Time

101 Ways to Earn Extra Money on the Side
201 Frugal and Perfect Birthday Gifts
101 Ways to Save Money Everyday
101 Ways to be Better and Successful at Work
101 Ways to Save Environment and Energy
101 Frugal and Romantic Anniversary Ideas
101 Low-Cost Men's Fashion Ideas
101 Personal Finance Tips
101 Ways to Reuse Household Stuff
101 Things to Do, When Nothing to Do
101 College Graduation Gift Ideas
100 Tips for Ecommerce Startup
101 Ways to Enjoy Indoor During Winter

Popular Posts

Quick Cash - How to make $100 legally, in a day
Living well on less than $10,000 a Year
Top survey sites for side income
What to do when auto repair goes wrong
Where should I invest my money now?
20 Ways to be productive and happy at work
51 Ways to get out of debt
Be a better person in 15 days, 15 ways
Income ideas for retirees and senior citizens
51 side jobs for college students
Urgently need a large amount of money?
Should I buy or should I rent?
Best Personal loan providers
25 Ways to save environment
25 DIY car repairs to save money
How to decorate office cubicle
How to show your wife you care
50 Financial Rules for Success
51 Frugal weekend family activity ideas
Become Rich By Saving 1 Hour Of Daily Wage
How much do I need to save for retirement?
How to negotiate your salary

Follow us on FaceBook

About Author

SB

Blogger by choice and IT manager by profession. Finance is my passion and gardening is my greatest satisfaction. Born in India, settled in US, Husband and a father. I created this blog in 2011 with a vision to help others. Thanks for your patronage. More info on my "about" page.

View all posts


Subscribe

Join our community of 5000+ subscribers to increase net worth and build wealth

Advertisements

Personal Stories

How I got a new HP computer replaced
Was COVID circulating in USA in fall of 2019?
How my credit score went up 800+
Why I didn’t invest in Bitcoins
How I controlled impulses to buy things
Why this blog is named One Cent at a Time

Subscribe via Email

Site Disclaimer

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this web site are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Read full Affiliate disclosure


One Cent at a Time is published by SB. The opinions expressed herein by him are his own and not those of his employer or anyone else. All content on One Cent at a Time is for entertainment purposes only. By reading this blog, you agree that SB and/or One Cent at a Time is not responsible for any actions taken after reading this blog. For the full disclaimer, click here .

Major Media Mention

One Cent at a Time Media Appearances

Copyright © 2022 One Cent At A Time · Designed by Nuts and Bolts Media